Chross has made an excellent spanking clip from the 1929 movie Lucky Star. I’ll commend you to his site for full details and links for high-quality downloads; meanwhile, for as long as it lasts, I’m going to do a rare YouTube embed. This is good stuff! He’s a rough working man with hard hands and leather gloves, she (Janet Gaynor) gnaws and bites his leg when he puts her over his knee, harsh words (on title cards) are exchanged, and after the spanking she spends a lot of time rubbing her sore bottom while they both emote like hell:
Any staging or framing comments on my part would spoil the fun. This is an excerpt of something at Alison Tyler’s blog; you’ll be remiss (and missing out) if you don’t go read it:
I thought until the end—until nearly the last possible moment—that he was going to spank her. Not me. Her. He ought to have. She was bitchy, bratty. The kind of girl who never gives you the time of day unless other people are watching. You know the type. I know the type. I thought he understood.
I was a pet. A plaything. I was this couple’s toy—and he, well, he was my friend, wasn’t he? Not just the Top. The Dom, Mr. All That. He accepted the fact that she—ice princess, butter wouldn’t melt in her snatch—was lying.
How bold I was. In that too-short dove gray nightgown. No panties. Curled up on the couch while she talked about someone needing a spanking. And I thought, oh, lord help me, I actually thought, Hell, yeah. She does. And I was going to enjoy watching him punish her perfect, pristine, size two little ass. So when he sat down on the emerald leather couch next to me, when he started to stroke the huge, glossy, black, hard-backed hairbrush next to *me*—I was dumbfounded.
“You only use that on her,” I said, stuttered, begged, whispered. All the words, all the ways you could say those words. “I mean, you’re going to use that on her… Not…”
You’ve heard about the benefits of an exclusive education, right? Well, apparently these benefits include lots of swift and very public spankings in front of the whole class:

From Exclusive Education 5 at Clare Fonda Pass. If you love lots and lots of spanked bottoms all in a row, this is the production for you.
See Also:
Wearing a dunce cap is humiliating enough. Wearing a dunce cap with no clothes on? That’s gotta be bad.
Found on a tumblr blog that’s not there any more, original source not known.
It’s a squalid situation. The private investigator has compromising photos, and if she doesn’t want her husband to see them, she has to do all of the kinky things the PI wants. The least of these is the bondage caning…
From Sex And Submission.
See Also:
This surprisingly modern-looking gagged spanking illustration is actually by Georges Töpfer, illustrating a vintage French erotic book called Visites fantastiques au pays du fouet by Aimé Van Rod:
To my eye, it looks very much in the modern style. But no; the vintage attribution is solid. It turns out ErosBlog published one of the other illustrations a couple of weeks ago, and managed to crowdsource an attribution to this wonderful post at Au carrefour étrange containing all of the illustrations from the book in glorious high resolution. Awesome.
See Also: