Gargoyle Press 1930s Spanking Titles #1: The Strap Returns

The Strap Returns -- cover images

After posting the Gargoyle Press magazine advertisement the other day, I grew curious to see what information could be found about the “curious and absorbing volumes on strange amatory customs and practices” issued by that publisher. Available information seems far from complete, but I was able to turn up a few titles published, roughly speaking, in that pre-war decade:

  • Saddler, Jean, A Fascinating Tyrant, Gargoyle Press, 1930. 10 illustrations by Terry Van Rees.
  • Meusal, Walter J., Painful Pleasures, Gargoyle Press, 1931. 18 illustrations by Francis Heuber.
  • Anonymous, The Strap Returns: new notes on flagellation, Gargoyle Press, 1933. Illustrations by Vladimir Alexandre Karenin.
  • Meusal, Walter J., Invitation to the Dance: a miscellany of stories, experiences, letters, articles, on Corporal Punishment, critically assessed and indulgently considered, Gargoyle Press, 1935. Illustrations by E. Remsen. Alternative title: Dance of Pain.
  • Paddock, Raymond, Smart education, or, The Miracle of Three Months, Gargoyle Press, 1940.

Gargoyle Press seems to have survived at least in name into the 1970s, judging by numerous stroke books published under that imprint. I don’t have any insight, though, into whether there was any continuity of business, or whether the stroke book publishers of the 1960s and 1970s merely “borrowed” a defunct but well-remembered erotic books brand name to sell more dirty paperbacks. Anyway, this post is about the titles that might have been advertised in the illustrated booklet advertised in 1935. Specifically, here’s what I could learn about The Strap Returns, from various online sources, even though I could not turn up any complete scan or digital copy of the text. (I hope to research the other titles in future posts.)

The Strap Returns appears to have consisted, in the words of its own editor/compiler as reported by one bibliographer, of “letters, excerpts, and articles selected by the editor from a huge quantity of clippings, translations, and the like.” The famous flagellation book The Whip And The Rod contains a passage describing The Strap Returns as “that amusing and interesting collection of anecdotes of material dealing with modern aspects of flagellation”, adding that it contains “many opinions in favor of corporal punishment”.

At least one bookseller offers the following table of contents as part of their bibliographic description:

  • Editor’s Note.
  • Miscellany and Authentic Episodes.
  • A Governess Lectures On the Art of Spanking.
  • A Group of Letters.
  • Home Discipline.
  • Five Provocative Contributions.
  • A Woman’s Revenge.
  • The Price of a Silk Handkerchief.

Evocative, but sadly far from descriptive!

Although I could learn little more than the above about the textual content of The Strap Returns, we are fortunate to have high-quality scans of the frontispiece and all of the artwork, from the careful collector at the Paris Olympia Press blog. I leave you with his generous scannings-and-sharings:

frontispiece

lesbian whipping

held down for spanking

spanked over a wooden bolster

otk spanking

public spanking at a party

femdom birching of a buff bound man

See Also:

  1. Goddess with a Whip commented on July 12th, 2021:

    The strap returns? Did it go anywhere? Not mine!! Been hanging where it belongs all along. Now where did that little one go? The OTK one. Hmmm…

Leave A Comment

Maximum Comment Length: 2500 characters (about five paragraphs)



A "Punished Delinquents In Tears" Movie:

Detention House 3: Spanked Inmates Made Very Sorry

blubbering blonde with a beaten ass
"...a heavy round wooden paddle with a hole in the middle that leaves fearsome red bruises. And then the shaking girls with beaten butts and tearful faces receive another terrible punishment..."